Thoughts?

Everything in the tier list is in order as well not placed just randomly within the tier. Ex: We prefer Ant-Man over Hawkeye

Commentaires

Powerofx12025-12-13 20:18

I like it, just move Agatha to B and Captain Marvel to Buns and is a perfect ranking

Flamezz2232025-12-13 20:18

Move she hulk

rgamefreak2025-12-13 20:19

Can you send this tier list link so I can do my own?

SvodolaDarkfury2025-12-13 20:20

I feel like this is generally in line with me, except Secret Invasion needs its own horrible category. Every other project has SOME redeeming quality. SI was just so bad.

Edit again: I don't think anything would be below a C for me though. SI is like F territory, but everything else I can find some enjoyment in.

pontiflexrex2025-12-13 20:20

wOmEn BaD.

Beckett-Papa2025-12-13 20:21

WandaVision is literally in A

pontiflexrex2025-12-13 20:22

“I have a black friend” rhetorics is not an exemption from the original point.

Beckett-Papa2025-12-13 20:24

Just because a movie or show’s lead actor is female doesn’t mean it is automatically good. The quality of those movies and shows are not even remotely close to the the same quality as films like Guardians of The Galaxy Vol. 3 or Thunderbolts*

pontiflexrex2025-12-13 20:28

And now you’re inventing a point to argue against as a way to feel good about your reaction (as if I said any movies with female lead MUST be good).

You literally ranked all the movies and - by your own criteria - it happens that all movies with female leads and dead last (not middle, dead last) but one.

It might mean something or the other, but yeah, you basically concluded that “wOmEn BaD” in marvel.

Beckett-Papa2025-12-13 20:31

Your point insinuated I am against women with the “WoMeN bAd” comment. You yourself believe that because I put obviously weaker films in a weaker category that I must be against women in Marvel because those weaker films or shows have female leads. Make it make sense. They simply put, are not better than the other projects on this list.

pontiflexrex2025-12-13 20:36

Your appeal to an imaginary objectivity in ranking movies is senseless. The point of rankings is to be subjective and not objective. So nothing is “obviously weaker” and that clear cut, by nature.

You want to pretend you’re not biased, you can live in that delusion but I can’t validate it for you.

Fortunately you belong to a notoriously turbo-toxic and misogynistic community in Marvels superfans, so others will soon come to reinforce your bias and don’t worry, you’ll soon feel like your opinion is once again “universally objective and obviously obvious”.

Beckett-Papa2025-12-13 20:44

Sorry that I subjectively find those films and shows boring and flat. I can respect the fact that movies and shows are subjective and you’re absolutely right about that.

I suppose I shouldn’t have used the “obviously weaker” term because we’re in a debate. So, I’ll rephrase, In MY opinion they are not the same quality as everything else on this list and you may have a different opinion than me and that is ok.

However, do not attack me for being a misogynist based off a tier list that is my opinion and I think those movies and shows are weaker than everything else on this list. You’ve never even met me. You’re judging my character based on a tier list that is so ridiculous but I guess that is Reddit and the internet for you.

FuelGlobal56522025-12-13 20:27

wOmEn lEaD sO gOoD

EcksFountain1322025-12-13 20:28

I'm a woman and the only categorization I really disagreed with on the chart was Black Widow. I'd have put that higher: but honestly no issue with the rest. About how I'd rank.

FF-LoZ2025-12-13 23:13

![gif](giphy|4a1f475nY27jaWCrgZ)

IkeaBreads2025-12-13 20:21

Agatha and Hawkeye my beloveds :(

BetterBugu2025-12-13 20:22

Avengers and Eternals, both being in the same group B, that's just wrong.

WallStreetWets2025-12-13 20:22

I’d probably switch Guardian’s 3 & 1. I feel like you’ll get flack for Loki being S and Winter Solider A, but I actually respect it. I loved Loki. First Avengers could be A. All in all, a solid list.

Beckett-Papa2025-12-13 20:25

Thank you Thank you

Mdad19882025-12-13 20:23

X-Men 97 bad? Sheesh what year were you born lol

Nemesis_1712025-12-13 20:28

He put it in haven’t seen

Mdad19882025-12-13 21:19

To be fair............ Tooooooooooo be fair..... I just didn't think there was any reason this was bottom tier. Unless someone young was like this is trash, and with nostalgia I can't really see it the way they might

![gif](giphy|4Z9g0DdoJPChn481o6)

YESRedbone2025-12-13 20:25

Solid tier list overall. Needs more upvotes.

PoolPartyWithoutTheL2025-12-13 20:26

I like the list, even know I know mine would be wildly different. But for the sake of discussion I'll pick the ones I find overrated and underrated.

Would be lower in my list: Black Panther

Would be higher in my list: Either Black Widow, or Ironheart.

CommunityDragon1842025-12-13 20:26

Ms marvel rocked

EcksFountain1322025-12-13 20:26

So are S and A top teir? I generally agree although I'd put TFA and Black Widow higher.

Pure_Beginning_79192025-12-13 20:27

Loki top tier

Affectionate_Toe71672025-12-13 20:28

BUNS

Operator_Starlight2025-12-13 20:28

Iron Man is not C Tier, come on.

Biden2028-2025-12-13 20:32

NWH S, Ms Marvel and Moon Knight A

imnpudd2025-12-13 20:36

Is the theme of agatha is what makes you dislikes it? Witches, fantasy etc?

marvelstudios-ModTeam2025-12-13 23:47

... your post lacked enough effort to promote new or productive discussion to the subreddit. If you're attempting to start a discussion with a low effort screenshot or video, try making a text post where you analyse the topic of the discussion and offer your own opinion.

If you're asking an open-ended question, try to add your own personal answer and the reasoning.